Legendary Idols Collide With Their Makers
At the center of this high-profile legal showdown are NJZ, the group formerly known as NewJeans, and their management agency, ADOR, a subsidiary of entertainment giant HYBE. NJZ (NewJeans) is a famed K-pop girl group composed of Minji, Hanni, Danielle, Haerin, and Hyein, known for their groundbreaking sound and rapid global ascent. ADOR, on the other hand, is the label that oversaw their success and propelled them onto the world stage.
Table of Contents
Battle Lines Drawn Over Creative Freedom vs. Contract Clauses
The dispute revolves around the validity and terms of NJZ’s exclusive contract with ADOR. What started as a behind-the-scenes industry clash has now exploded into a legal battle with implications for the K-pop world and artist management at large.
NJZ is fighting to be released from the agency’s exclusive hold, claiming mistreatment, broken trust, and fundamental changes within ADOR that make reconciliation impossible. ADOR counters that they have fulfilled all obligations and that the sudden attempt by NJZ to unilaterally terminate their contract lacks legal standing and risks severe financial loss for the company.
From Shattered Trust to the Courtroom Spotlight
The saga began publicly in November 2023, when NJZ, through their lawyers, moved to terminate their contract with ADOR, citing irreparable trust issues and a lack of faith following the ouster of former CEO Min Hee-jin—a pivotal figure in their formation and creative direction. Matters escalated rapidly, leading to multiple court hearings through 2024 and into 2025. The latest significant hearing took place on July 24, 2025, at the Seoul Central District Court.
Seoul: The Epicenter of a Pop Culture Earthquake
All legal proceedings have been held in South Korea, primarily in the Seoul Central District Court, which has become the stage for this pivotal test of artist rights, contract enforcement, and agency power within the music industry.
Trust Broken, Ties Severed: What Fueled the Meltdown?
Two issues lie at the heart of the conflict:
- Change in leadership and trust: The group claims that following an audit by parent company HYBE and the replacement of Min Hee-jin as CEO, the spirit and management of ADOR altered significantly, leading to an irreparable breakdown in trust. The group’s legal team insists they could only return if ADOR reverts to its pre-audit state, which appears unlikely.
- Contractual rights vs. agency interests: NJZ argues their creative freedom and well-being are being hampered under the current management. ADOR maintains they have honored their commitments, investing heavily in the group and providing each member with large financial settlements; thus, they argue, the contract should stand to safeguard both parties’ interests.
The Legal Chess Game: Every Move Under Scrutiny
- Initial Moves: The legal rift began in late 2023 with NJZ seeking termination, citing mistreatment and broken trust.
- ADOR’s Response: The agency filed for an injunction, securing a court order in March 2024 that barred NJZ/NewJeans from acting independently or signing advertising contracts outside the agency.
- Escalation: As of the June 2025 rulings, NJZ faced potential penalties of 1 billion won (about $734,000) per member for unauthorized activities. A final appeal by NJZ to overturn the injunction was denied in June 2025, solidifying ADOR’s control over the group’s activities.
- Future Proceedings: On July 24, 2025, the Court confirmed a closed-door mediation for August 14. The mediation will determine whether reconciliation is possible or if the parties will part ways definitively.
Contract Under the Microscope: The Stakes for Both Sides
NJZ’s contract, considered standard in the K-pop industry, is a seven-year exclusive agreement binding the group to ADOR. Such contracts place almost all musical, personal appearance, and commercial rights in the hands of the agency. Terminating the contract prematurely exposes NJZ to significant financial penalties and claims from ADOR for lost investments and breach of contract.
ADOR claims it provided each NJZ member with settlements totaling 5 billion won (about $3.75 million) and invested nearly 21 billion won in the group’s development, underscoring the financial magnitude of the case.
Meet the Players: The Powerhouses Behind the Headlines
NJZ (NewJeans): Pop Stars at a Crossroads
- Debuted: July 2022.
- Members: Minji, Hanni, Danielle, Haerin, Hyein.
- Known for: Hit singles like “Attention,” “Super Shy,” and “OMG”; viral fan engagement; trailblazing Y2K-inspired style.
- Achievements: Billboard Hot 100 entries, Guinness World Records for streams, global endorsement deals.
ADOR: The Creative Giant Facing Its Own Storm
- Subsidiary label under HYBE, one of the world’s top K-pop entertainment conglomerates.
- Led creativity and brand development for NewJeans under Min Hee-jin until internal audits, corporate shifts, and the ouster of key staff soured the relationship.
Read other story: 5 K-pop Stars’ Habits That Will Change Your Life
Fans, Frenzy, and Fallout: The World Weighs In
NJZ’s Stance: ‘We Want Our Voices Back’
NJZ’s legal team has been clear: their willingness to return depends on leadership changes at ADOR. They emphasize the negative impact on the members’ mental health and artistic creativity under current management.
ADOR Fires Back: ‘Don’t Forget Who Built the Stage’
ADOR insists that the group’s unprecedented international success owes itself to the agency’s support, investment, and management. They describe the abrupt attempted exit as damaging and unjustified.
Fandoms at War, Social Media Erupts
The rift has split audiences. Some fans stand by NJZ, empathizing with their claims of mistreatment and desire for independence. Others believe the agency’s investment warrants contract enforcement, criticizing NJZ’s perceived ingratitude and questioning the wisdom of breaking industry norms. Online forums and social media are awash with lively debate, with many expressing frustration over the lack of resolution and the industry’s opaque management style.
Legal Watchers Await the Next Precedent
Legal experts are divided—some believe NJZ’s arguments about leadership changes constitute actionable reasons for termination, while others point to the group’s ongoing commercial success as proof the contract was not breached. Industry insiders note this case may set precedent for future disputes between idols and agencies.
Echoes of the Past: K-Pop’s Battle-Tested Precedents
- TVXQ and SM Entertainment: One of K-pop’s first and most infamous contract disputes, with TVXQ’s eventual split leading to industry reforms regarding contract duration and fairness.
- KARA vs DSP Media and EXO vs SM Entertainment: Both involved idol groups seeking exit from their agencies over alleged mistreatment or unfair contract terms. In most cases, courts have sided with agencies unless there was clear evidence of contractual breach or unlawful treatment.
These cases reveal a pattern: courts uphold exclusive contracts unless artists can clearly prove gross misconduct or agreements beyond the contract’s scope.
Next Episode: August Mediation or Total Meltdown?
The outcome of the August 14 closed-door mediation will be pivotal. If the two sides reach an agreement, it could result in a substantial monetary settlement, revised contract terms, or the group’s departure from ADOR. If mediation fails and further litigation ensues, NJZ may face considerable financial penalties, while ADOR risks damage to its public image and business interests.
No matter how this drama ends, the ripples will be felt across the K-pop universe, changing how idols negotiate, sign, and challenge their contracts for years to come.
